Wednesday, February 17, 2016

Collector's Guide to Libbey Nash Silhouette

If rare, beautiful glass grabs your interest, check out Libbey's very rare figural stemware from the 1930s: Libbey Nash Silhouette. This figural glass has sleek animal stems that display beautifully and is among the rarest of glass. It's rare enough, some antique dealers don't recognize it, which makes it that much more exciting to find. 

In 1931, Libbey Glass launched an upscale Art Deco line led by a former Tiffany executive, Douglas Nash. Unfortunately, the release crashed headlong into the Great Depression. The pricey glassware nearly sank Libbey Glass. The Libbey Nash line closed after less than two years in production. 

Among the Libbey-Nash venture is the rare Silhouettes line. I classify them into tiers based on rarity. I also look at stem color, as the initial catalog showed only moonstone (opalescent) and black, but most pieces are also found in frosted (or satin). Tier 1 pieces, though uncommon, pop up the most. Tier 2 is even less common, and the price varies with things like season, auction house and whether a bidding war engages. Tier 3 is extremely rare and prices are higher, and seriously market-driven.

Each Libbey Nash Silhouette glass type has a distinct animal figure, so the Kangaroo stem is always on the Cocktail, for example. To me, it's a treasure hunt, which makes them fun to collect. Note that these pieces are sometimes not marked, but they are still Libbey Silhouettes. These have not been reproduced, and while other glass makers created figural stemware, no one else made these. The mark is a script Libbey in circle, which may be faint. I have one unmarked piece with a small Libbey sticker intact. 
           
Frosted Kangaroo

Tier 1: Kangaroo, Monkey & Greyhound

The Kangaroo Cocktail, though rare, is most common of the Silhouettes. Frosted Kangaroo (satin glass) seems most common to me; opalescent moonstone is next; black is least common. A Kangaroo Cocktail in amber or red shoots it to the top of the rarity list. NOTE: Only the stem color changes. 

Frosted Monkey


The Monkey Sherry . The frosted and moonstone Monkeys are about equally rare with the black less common. I’ve never seen another color in the monkey, so if you see an amber or red stemmed monkey, it’s rare! Side note: Of my four Monkey Sherrys, only one has the acid-etched signature. 



Black & Moonstone Greyhound Cordials


The Greyhound Cordial is next in rarity, in my experience, and possibly belongs in Tier 2. The moonstone stem shows up often  enough to call it Tier 1, although the variations are very rare. Black Greyhound Cordials are rarer yet, and Satin Frosted are very rare. The Greyhound takes some study, because it doesn’t look like a Greyhound to me. It’s a sleek, stylized figure. My moonstone and black are marked. My satin frosted are unmarked.





Tier 2: Squirrel, Cat, Rabbit & Bear


These next 4 are pretty close in rarity, with exceptions for variations.


Hollow Stem Squirrel
The Squirrel Champagne is a saucer champagne, most likely to surface in  moonstone. A variation on the Squirrel Champagne is the Hollow Stem (shown here). A tall hollow stem raises the bowl and also the rarity factor. Hollow Stem Squirrel Champagnes pop up very, very rarely, so much they probably belong in the Tier 3 group.  The Squirrel Champagne is the only Silhouette with this hollow stem variation, to my knowledge. I stayed up until 2 a.m. to bid on one, and still lost out. (More on Squirrel variations below.)


Moonstone Cat Goblet
Black Cat Stem


Cat Goblets. Cat Goblets show up most commonly in frosted and opalescent, with black less common. Price varies with color and depending on whether you want a whole set. 
Note on sets: A complete set is breathtaking! Yet, to me, one of each piece creates a museum. Ours are for display only, so we're happy with one of each.




Black Rabbit Sherbet

Rabbit Sherbets are squat, broad bowled glasses. Like the Greyhound, recognizing a Rabbit Sherbet takes a keen eye. Rabbits are rare in any color. A moonstone rabbit sold in 2015 on Live Auctioneers for $200. Add the 21% buyer’s premium, and the price totals $242. 
NOTE: The rabbit stem also was made as a vase. According to Fauster's book, these are not part of the original catalog, but others have told me they were indeed advertised from the beginning. They are also very rare.

Frosted Bear Claret


The Bear Claret is rare, although availability varies widely. You can go for many months and not see one, then have a few pop up at the same time. Like most others, they may exists in amber or red, but I haven’t seen one. For a real deal, don't pass up an unmarked Bear Claret, which can go for well under $100. They're still Libbey, still the real thing, and just may complete your collection of Libbey Nash Silhouettes.






Uncut Glass Squirrel
Cut Flowers & Initials
SPECIAL NOTES: Squirrel. A variation not in the original catalog appears often enough to warrant discussion: An uncut Squirrel. Some call it an ivy bowl, brandy snifter, or an unfinished piece their great-uncle sneaked home in a lunch box. 

The real story, as I understand it: These were available during tours of the Libbey factory in the 1930s. They are glass, not leaded crystal as the rest of the line is. Some have elaborate, skillfully cut monograms or patterns, which we find especially cool to own. Glass cutting was art and skill, and being a 1930s Master Glasscutter was an honor. These can be found cut with initials or designs. 



Tier 3: Very rare, Camel, Giraffe & Elephant
All are very rare and beautiful.

Camel Candlesticks are taller than the stemware. 
We were thrilled to add these to our collection. Very rare in any color, even a solo candlestick is a find. The best deal I saw was an opalescent Camel Candlestick set that went for $300 (plus 20% buyer’s premium) sold at auction where it was advertised simply as Libbey. Not Nash. Not Silhouette. Not rare. (Had I been there, I would have jumped on it.)
The lesson here: When buying: search "Libbey," and go through listings. If selling: list with Libbey Nash Silhouette + animal name & size.

The Giraffe Compote is one of the most coveted Libbey Nash Silhouette pieces. It is tall and beautiful with lovely lines. It is extremely rare in any color.

The elusive Elephant Bowl tops the list. One long-time collector says he has every piece, but has never even seen an elephant bowl, other than at the Libbey Glass Museum. We have seen opalescent and black elephant bowls. We don't own one.

Note on marks: When marked, these have the acid-etched script "Libbey" in circle mark. However, Libbey Nash Silhouette pieces have not been reproduced. Even if unmarked, it is the genuine article. Some collectors avoid unmarked pieces, so these may sell for less, but as a collector, whether it's marked makes little difference to me. They are the real deal. 

The Libbey-Nash era produced other beautiful glassware, all of which is very rare, and perhaps for another blog post, another day.

Note on selling: In the past, I mentioned Ebay as a good place to sell your Libbey Silhouette pieces, but I no longer advocate for this. Recently, I saw two pieces of the rarest Libbey Silhouette pieces sell on Ebay auction for less than I believe they would have sold elsewhere. Ebay has a hard close; the time it ends is fixed. Other auctions use a soft close, so any bid in the last few minutes extends the closing, allowing competing bids to be entered. Until Ebay finds a way to offer the soft close, my advice is to either set your price, or offer your Silhouettes at an auction such as Jeffrey Evans, DuMouchelles or another reputable auction house specializing in high-end collectibles.  


Join in the conversation! If you have pieces you'd like to share or sell, pieces you're looking for, or you have knowledge to share, we're always looking to learn more. This blog has been revised as information comes to us, so please join in!

Until then, Happy Hunting! May your treasures be many!

---Jennie Dugan, RDJ's Antiques. 

(Updated 03/11/2022, JD)





           


20 comments:

  1. Nancy, believe it or not, they sell well on Ebay. If you do it by auction, you can set a reserve price. You could also consign them with a good auction house like Jeffrey Evans or Dumouchelles, but I would only put them with a high end auction house like those. Also, last and definitely not least, I'd be interested in any pieces I don't already have. Please feel free to let me know if you want to sell!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have been collecting and selling these stems for years. The IVY Bowl squirrel stem was reportedly a factory tour give-a-way item in later years using the old mold.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Replies
    1. I happen to have the opalescent moonstone rabbit vase, and it is signed.

      Delete
    2. That is such an exciting find! Do you know anything about when the vase was produced? I'm interested in learning more about all Libbey, and definitely the Silhouette line. Thanks for your post!

      Delete
  4. I'm pretty sure the rabbit vase was released at the same time as the rest of the animal stems. Even though Fauster doesn't include it in his book, I have found other references to the rabbit vase. One actually included the price which was $6. I have a 1972 Spinning Wheel magazine that has an article about them and lists the price of each at their issue. I haven't been to the Glass Museum lately I'm curious if they have one on display still.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I recently came across a number of bear clarets. It looks like eBay is my best option to sell although I am looking at getting ahold of the Libbey glass museum. Do people buy these as sets or am I better off to keep them individual to sell?

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'm sorry I didn't respond sooner to your June 2019 question. From what I see, they'll sell either way. You don't often see a whole set for sale.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I have an elephant bowl, it was cut by my great grandfather who was a glass cutter for Libbey. What is it worth?

    ReplyDelete
  8. On the cut elephant bowl: What you have is unique, and you have the provenance of your grandfather cutting it. An elephant bowl can go for $1,000 and sometimes more. A cut or engraved elephant bowl will surely go for more, especially at a reputable auction house with a reputation for fine glass (like Jeffrey Evans, Woody, DuMouchelles; if you're in Toledo, consider Whalen Auctions which has some beautiful glass auctions that bring good prices for the sellers). I'd insure it for $2500, I suppose, but that's a guess as there's nothing to base it on. It may not sell for that much at auction, or it may sell for more. I'd love to see it if you'd like to post a picture. If you do send it to auction, please let me know. I'm interested.

    ReplyDelete
  9. To be sure, I am interested in buying Libbey Silhouette pieces, especially those that I don't already have, but often it's most fair to the seller to send the pieces to auction. But if you have Libbey Silhouette pieces that you'd rather sell directly, and you'd like me to make you an offer, please contact me at jenniecdugan@gmail.com! Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  10. This may go without saying, but with the current situation, prices on Silhouettes are way down! If you're collecting, now's the time!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I responded via email, but will also respond here. Yes, I'm interested. What color is the stem? And did you have a price in mind? And also, just to be sure, no chips or cracks? Thanks so much for thinking of me.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thanks for letting me know that. You're correct, I didn't get your response. I adjusted the blog's settings now, so hopefully that will work. But will you email me directly at jenniecdugan@gmail.com?
    Thanks for thinking of me.
    Jennie

    ReplyDelete
  13. I have several Libbey Nash cat silhouette goblets for sale they are not signed and the stems are clear are they fakes?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They aren't fakes. The Libbey Silhouettes haven't been duplicated, to my knowledge. I also have some pieces that don't have the Libbey mark. Are the stems clear like crystal, or do they have an opalescence to them? The Libbey clear stems have the opalescence, although it's not overly pronounced. And does the glass ping like crystal when tapped? (It should.) Please feel free to share the link where you have them listed for sale on this thread. Thanks!

      Delete
  14. Hello again the glasses do have a nice ping like crystal when tapped the stems in my opinion are crystal clear with no opalescence I live in Toledo and purchased them at a local estate sale I have them listed in my E-bay store ID name allthisjunk4u

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Allthisjunk4u, I'm going to agree with you that your cats look like they're clear glass, rather than opalescent. I messaged someone else that I think is more expert than I am. I'm curious to learn about them. I've never seen clear glass cats. I have a couple of the clear glass squirrels, which were made for tours of the Libbey factory in the 1930s, as I understand it. I'll let you know what I hear, or perhaps someone else will weigh in here. I'm also going to ask the question on the Libbey Collectors Facebook page. Hopefully, someone will know something about these. Very interesting. Thanks for posting.

      Delete
  15. thanks for getting back to me Looking forward to getting more information on them

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. On the clear glass Cats: Another collector has told me these were originally produced in clear glass. That fits with your saying they ding like crystal. They seem rare to me. It's hard to gauge whether collectors find these more or less desirable, or on even-par with the others. Value would still be up to the collector. Thanks for bringing this up.

      Delete